Skip to main content
All stories

Island Peak vs Mera Peak: Which Should You Climb First?

Island Peak or Mera Peak for your first Himalayan climb? Compare altitude, technical difficulty, route, permits and the skills you'll need.

Journey Vibes Team · · 6 min read

The short answer

Mera Peak is higher, but it's generally the less technical climb. It's mostly a long glacier walk, so altitude is the main challenge. Island Peak is lower, but it involves more technical climbing near the top, including fixed ropes on a steep snow headwall and a narrow ridge. Which is right for you depends on how you handle altitude and how comfortable you are with ropes and exposure.

Mountaineering is dangerous. This is general planning information and not climbing instruction. Your guide will make the decisions on the mountain.

Side by side

Island Peak (Imja Tse)Mera Peak
Height6,189 mUsually given as about 6,476 m
Our itinerary17 days18 days
Main challengeTechnical sections, plus altitudeGreater altitude and a long summit day
Summit terrainGlacier, fixed ropes, steep headwall and narrow ridgeMostly long snow slopes on a glacier, steeper near the top
ApproachBusy Everest trail via Dingboche and ChhukhungQuieter Hinku valley
FacilitiesMore lodges on the approachSimpler in places
High campMany climbers leave from base campHigh camp usually around 5,780 m

Some sources give Mera as 6,461 m or 6,470 m. One guide grades Mera as PD and Island Peak as PD+ to AD-, although we couldn't confirm the source of that grading.

What Island Peak is like

You usually acclimatize on the Everest Base Camp trail, then move to Chhukhung and base camp. Summit day often starts after midnight. You cross a glacier, sometimes with crevasses, then climb a steep snow and ice headwall on fixed ropes to reach a narrow ridge and the summit.

You'll need to use crampons, an ice axe, a harness and an ascender, and you should be happy on exposed ground. Many operators run training at base camp, but prior practice is a real advantage.

Climbers on fixed ropes below the Island Peak summit
The fixed-rope headwall near the top of Island Peak.

What Mera Peak is like

You walk through remote forest and the Hinku valley to Khare, cross the Mera La onto the glacier, and move up to high camp. Summit day is long and cold, with slow, steady walking at very high altitude. It's often described as a trekker's climb, but that can be misleading. A short steeper section may need rope work, crevasses are possible, and at this height, every step is hard.

On a clear day, the summit view reaches Everest, Lhotse, Makalu, Cho Oyu and Kanchenjunga.

Sunset light on peaks in the Mera region
The Mera region is quieter than the main Everest trail.

How the summit days compare

Island PeakMera Peak
Night before the summit, on our plansBase camp, about 5,087 mHigh camp, about 5,780 m
Height to climb on the dayAbout 1,100 mAbout 700 m
Our estimated dayAbout 12 hours, back to ChhukhungAbout 10 hours, back to Khare
Acclimatization before the summitIncludes Everest Base Camp and Kala PattharIncludes a rest and training day at Khare

Other operators quote different times. For Mera, sources range from about 8 to 12 hours, with starts as early as 2 am. The table also shows why height alone doesn't tell the whole story. Mera has less climbing on summit day, but you sleep much higher the night before, which many people find hard. Island Peak has more height to gain and harder ground, but you've slept lower.

Our Mera plan also has a spare day for weather. Ask any operator whether their plan has one, because a single storm can end a summit attempt if there's no time left to wait.

Which should you choose?

If you…Consider
Want to learn and use technical skillsIsland Peak
Are nervous about exposure and ladders or ropesMera Peak
Have done well at high altitude beforeMera Peak is a natural goal
Want to see Everest Base Camp as wellIsland Peak
Prefer quieter trailsMera Peak
Have little or no winter experienceGet training first, whichever you choose

Success rates

We don't have reliable figures. One website gives about 50 to 70% for Island Peak, but it doesn't clearly source this, and we found no comparable number for Mera. Treat any summit rate carefully. Weather, the time you allow, and how you acclimatize all matter far more than a marketing number.

Permits

Climbing permits are arranged through your agency. Sources conflict on the fees. Older pages list US$250 in spring and US$125 in autumn for these peaks, while one 2025 source lists higher rates, such as US$500 in spring and US$250 in autumn. Ask your agency for the current fee from the Nepal Mountaineering Association.

You'll also need local permits. Island Peak uses Sagarmatha National Park and the Khumbu municipality fee, and Mera is reported to use Makalu Barun National Park plus local charges. See our permit guide.

When to go

Both are usually climbed in spring (March to May) and autumn (September to November). Winter brings severe cold, and summer monsoon brings poor weather.

How to prepare

  • Build endurance with long, loaded hill days.
  • Take a basic mountaineering course, covering crampons, ropes and ice axe use.
  • Gain altitude experience on a high trek first, if you can.
  • Make sure your insurance covers climbing at this height. Standard trekking cover often doesn't. See our insurance guide.
  • See a doctor who understands altitude. Read our altitude sickness guide.
  • Choose a plan with spare days for weather.

Common questions

Can a beginner climb these peaks?

Fit people with little climbing experience do attempt them with guides, but it's a big step. Learning the skills first makes it much safer and more enjoyable.

Can you climb both in one trip?

Some operators offer combined trips, which give good acclimatization but take much longer. They're best for experienced, very fit people.

What about Lobuche East?

Lobuche East is more technical than either, so it's better suited to people with some alpine experience.

Island Peak seen from Dingboche
Island Peak seen from the Dingboche area, on the main Everest trail.

Next steps

Compare the Island Peak and Mera Peak itineraries, or tell us about your experience and we'll advise you.

Sources and last checked
  • Climbing
  • Everest
  • Planning

Comments

Keep reading